When Does Dexter Get Good?
A new viewer will know within the first 2-3 episodes if Dexter is a show they will want to keep watching. That being said, buyer be warned, there is general fan and critic consensus that Dexter, while maintaining a strong quality for the first several seasons, definitely falls off in the later seasons to the point of ret-conning the series in very unfavorable directions.
What Fans Say:
Fans of Dexter praise its unique blend of crime thriller and dark comedy, anchored by Michael C. Hall’s phenomenal performance as Dexter Morgan. They commend the show’s ability to humanize a serial killer, creating a morally complex protagonist who follows a rigid “code” to target criminals who evade justice. Fans also appreciate the sharp storytelling, the tense cat-and-mouse dynamics with law enforcement, and the exploration of Dexter’s dual life as a blood spatter analyst and a killer. Season 4 is widely celebrated, with many calling it the show’s peak, thanks to the chilling villainy of John Lithgow’s Trinity Killer.
—
—
What Haters Say:
Critics of Dexter often point to its uneven later seasons as a source of frustration. They argue that the show stretches believability with convoluted plotlines and questionable character decisions. Some dislike the tonal shifts, claiming the show occasionally struggles to balance its dark humor with its grisly subject matter. The final season, particularly the series finale, is frequently derided as one of the most disappointing conclusions in TV history, leaving many fans feeling betrayed by its lack of closure and character resolution.
Does the Show Fall Off in Quality?
Yes, many viewers agree that Dexter experiences a decline in quality after its fourth season. Seasons 5 and 6, while still entertaining, fail to reach the heights of earlier seasons. The final two seasons (7 and 8) are particularly polarizing, with critics pointing to weak antagonists, repetitive themes, and an unsatisfying narrative trajectory. However, the revival series Dexter: New Blood attempts to address these issues, offering fans a more fitting conclusion.
Aggregated Critic Commentary:
Critics generally applaud the first four seasons for their tight plotting, compelling character arcs, and the balance of tension and dark humor. Michael C. Hall’s portrayal of Dexter Morgan earned critical acclaim and several awards. However, as the series progressed, reviews became more mixed, with later seasons criticized for declining storytelling quality and missed opportunities. The series finale of the original run received overwhelmingly negative feedback, though New Blood garnered a more positive response for course-correcting the narrative.
| Season | Rotten Tomatoes Score | IMDb Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Season 1 | 81% | 8.7 |
| Season 2 | 96% | 8.9 |
| Season 3 | 71% | 8.5 |
| Season 4 | 88% | 9.3 |
| Season 5 | 69% | 8.2 |
| Season 6 | 38% | 8.0 |
| Season 7 | 76% | 8.1 |
| Season 8 | 33% | 6.6 |
| New Blood | 77% | 8.1 |
Overview:
Dexter is a groundbreaking psychological thriller that follows Dexter Morgan, a blood spatter analyst for the Miami Metro Police Department by day and a vigilante serial killer by night. Based on Jeff Lindsay’s Darkly Dreaming Dexter novel series, the show delves into the inner workings of Dexter’s “dark passenger” and his strict moral code instilled by his adoptive father, Harry. With a supporting cast that includes Jennifer Carpenter as Dexter’s sister Debra, and standout guest stars like John Lithgow and Jimmy Smits, the show expertly weaves tension, humor, and emotion. The series explores themes of identity, morality, and the nature of justice, making it a thought-provoking yet entertaining watch.
Season Highlights:
Season 1: The inaugural season introduces Dexter Morgan and his “code,” exploring his attempts to maintain a normal life while indulging his need to kill. The Ice Truck Killer becomes Dexter’s first major adversary, with the mystery taking a personal turn as it’s revealed the killer is his biological brother, Brian. The season’s exploration of Dexter’s origins and the chilling family dynamic sets a strong foundation for the series.
Season 2: Dexter’s secret life is threatened when the bodies of his victims are discovered in the ocean, sparking the “Bay Harbor Butcher” investigation. The introduction of Lila, an unhinged romantic interest, adds further complexity to Dexter’s life. This season is lauded for its intense pacing and the clever way it forces Dexter to evade capture while maintaining his facade.
Season 3: Dexter forms a complicated friendship with Assistant District Attorney Miguel Prado, who discovers his secret and wishes to join him in his vigilante pursuits. The moral conflict and eventual breakdown of their alliance create compelling drama, though this season receives mixed reviews compared to its predecessors.
Season 4: Widely regarded as the pinnacle of the series, this season pits Dexter against the Trinity Killer, played masterfully by John Lithgow. The tension between Dexter’s family life and his dark urges reaches a crescendo, culminating in a shocking finale that leaves viewers reeling.
Season 5: In the aftermath of Season 4’s devastating conclusion, Dexter grapples with guilt and grief. He teams up with Lumen, a survivor of a trafficking ring, to hunt down her tormentors. While praised for its emotional depth, some fans feel this season struggles to maintain the momentum of its predecessor.
Season 6: Dexter faces off against the Doomsday Killer, a religious zealot. This season is often criticized for its disjointed storytelling and an over-the-top villain, though it does feature significant developments in Debra’s realization of Dexter’s secret.
Season 7: The tension between Dexter and Debra reaches new heights as she grapples with his true nature. The introduction of Hannah McKay, a romantic interest and fellow killer, adds intrigue. Critics appreciate the attempt to delve deeper into character relationships, but the season’s pacing draws mixed reactions.
Season 8: The final season of the original run sees Dexter confronting Dr. Evelyn Vogel, a psychiatrist with ties to his past. The series attempts to tie up loose ends but falters in execution, with the controversial finale alienating many fans. The decision to have Dexter fake his death and live in isolation as a lumberjack is widely panned.
Dexter: New Blood: Set nearly a decade after the original series, the revival follows Dexter’s new life in a small town under the alias Jim Lindsay. When his son, Harrison, re-enters his life, Dexter is forced to confront his past. New Blood is praised for its darker tone and more satisfying conclusion, though some feel it’s a bittersweet ending.
Similar Shows:
- Breaking Bad – A gripping exploration of morality and transformation, with a flawed antihero at its core.
- Hannibal – A visually stunning and psychologically intense show about a brilliant psychiatrist with a dark secret.
- The Sopranos – A complex crime drama focusing on the personal and professional struggles of a mob boss.
- Mindhunter – A cerebral exploration of criminal psychology and the origins of FBI profiling.
- Bates Motel – A modern prequel to Psycho that delves into the relationship between Norman Bates and his mother.
If You Liked These, You’ll Like This Show:
- True Detective – For fans of dark, atmospheric crime dramas with morally ambiguous characters.
- Ozark – A tense and tightly plotted series about a family navigating the criminal underworld.
- The Shield – A gritty police drama with complex characters and ethical dilemmas.
- Six Feet Under – Another Michael C. Hall-starring series, this one focusing on a family-run funeral home and existential themes.