When Does Barry Get Good?
Barry will be a hit or a miss for you within the first 2-3 episodes, and for new fans, will remain strong through the series run. For those expecting to perhaps like it in later seasons, if you’re not connecting early with the series, you likely won’t find new fandom by sticking it out too much longer than that.
What Fans Say:
Fans of Barry praise its seamless blend of dark comedy and intense drama. They highlight the show’s sharp writing, unique premise of a hitman trying to pursue an acting career, and stellar performances, especially by Bill Hader as the titular character and Henry Winkler as his acting coach, Gene Cousineau. The series’ ability to balance dark, violent moments with humor and heartfelt character development is frequently lauded. Many viewers appreciate the depth of Barry’s internal conflict and the exploration of morality, trauma, and identity.
—
—
What Haters Say:
Some detractors argue that Barry suffers from tonal inconsistency, making it difficult to determine whether the show wants to be a comedy or a tragedy. A few viewers feel that certain plot twists stretch believability, particularly as Barry’s double life becomes more complicated. Critics also mention that some supporting characters—despite strong performances—lack sufficient development compared to the leads. Others contend that the pacing can feel uneven, with slower episodes focusing heavily on introspection rather than plot progression.
Does the Show Fall Off in Quality at Any Point?
Many fans and critics agree that Barry maintains a high level of quality throughout its run. However, opinions diverge when discussing the show’s third and fourth seasons. Some viewers feel that the tone becomes darker and more introspective as the series progresses, shifting away from the humor that initially defined it. While this tonal shift is praised by those who appreciate complex character studies, others miss the balance of comedy and action found in earlier seasons.
Aggregated Critic Commentary:
| Season | Rotten Tomatoes Approval | Rotten Tomatoes Average Score | IMDb Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Season 1 (2018) | 98% | 8.1/10 | 8.5/10 |
| Season 2 (2019) | 100% | 8.8/10 | 9.3/10 |
| Season 3 (2022) | 99% | 9.05/10 | 9.0/10 |
| Season 4 (2023) | 96% | 9.05/10 | 8.3/10 |
Critics have consistently praised Barry for its originality, tight storytelling, and standout performances. Bill Hader’s portrayal of Barry Berkman has earned acclaim for capturing the character’s emotional turmoil and moral ambiguity. Henry Winkler’s performance as Gene Cousineau has been similarly celebrated, earning him multiple awards. Critics appreciate the show’s ability to subvert genre conventions by blending Hollywood satire, crime thriller elements, and existential themes. The direction, often helmed by Hader himself, is recognized for its meticulous craftsmanship and inventive action sequences.
Overview:
Barry, created by Bill Hader and Alec Berg, premiered on HBO in 2018. The series follows Barry Berkman, a disillusioned hitman from the Midwest who stumbles into an acting class while on a job in Los Angeles. As Barry attempts to leave his violent past behind and pursue a new passion for acting, he finds himself drawn deeper into the criminal underworld. The show masterfully blends dark comedy with suspense and psychological drama, exploring themes of identity, redemption, and the consequences of violence.
With its sharp writing, memorable characters, and moral complexity, Barry quickly became a critical darling and a fan favorite. Bill Hader’s performance as Barry earned widespread acclaim, showcasing his range as both a comedic and dramatic actor. The series’ unique mix of humor and darkness sets it apart from traditional crime dramas, offering a fresh and compelling narrative about a man caught between two worlds.
Season Highlights:
Season 1 (2018):
The first season introduces Barry Berkman, a hitman who discovers a passion for acting after following a target into an acting class. He forms a bond with his acting teacher, Gene Cousineau, and fellow student Sally Reed. Barry’s attempts to leave his criminal life behind are complicated by his handler, Fuches, and a violent Chechen mob led by NoHo Hank. Season 1 expertly balances humor and drama, culminating in a tense finale where Barry confronts the reality of his choices.
Season 2 (2019):
Season 2 delves deeper into Barry’s struggle to suppress his violent instincts. Gene Cousineau faces a personal tragedy, leading to a more emotionally charged mentorship dynamic with Barry. The season also explores Sally’s backstory and her confrontation with past trauma. A standout episode, “ronny/lily,” showcases Barry’s brutal fight with a martial arts expert and his feral daughter. The season’s darker tone and complex moral questions elevate the storytelling.
Season 3 (2022):
In Season 3, Barry grapples with the escalating consequences of his actions as his relationships begin to unravel. Gene discovers the truth about Barry’s past, leading to intense confrontations. The season examines themes of guilt, redemption, and the cyclical nature of violence. Critics highlight the increasingly tense narrative and the deeper exploration of Barry’s psyche, though some fans note a shift away from the humor of earlier seasons.
Season 4 (2023):
The final season brings Barry’s journey to a dramatic conclusion. The series explores whether redemption is possible for someone with Barry’s violent history. Gene’s role in Barry’s life reaches a critical point, and the narrative threads of previous seasons converge in a tense and emotionally charged finale. While the darker tone remains divisive, many praise the show’s willingness to challenge audience expectations and deliver a thought-provoking ending.
Similar Shows:
- Fargo – A darkly comedic crime anthology series with quirky characters and unexpected violence.
- Breaking Bad – The transformation of a mild-mannered man into a ruthless criminal mastermind.
- Better Call Saul – A character-driven prequel exploring moral ambiguity and complex relationships.
- The Sopranos – A psychological exploration of a mob boss balancing family and crime.
- Killing Eve – A cat-and-mouse thriller with dark humor and complex characters.
If You Liked These, You’ll Like Barry:
- Archer – A darkly comedic animated series about a dysfunctional spy agency.
- BoJack Horseman – A blend of humor and existential drama centered on a washed-up actor.
- Dexter – A serial killer grappling with a desire for normalcy.
- GLOW – A mix of comedy and drama set in the world of women’s wrestling.