When Does Justified Get Good?
For most viewers, you’ll know whether or not Justified will be a show you should keep watching within the first 2-3 episodes. Justified picks a style and sticks with it for its entire run. Most fans will tell a new viewer the show keeps high quality over the entire run, with small dips here and there, but season-by-season Justified is a rewarding series.
What Fans Say
Fans of Justified praise its sharp dialogue, rich character development, and masterful performances, particularly Timothy Olyphant as U.S. Marshal Raylan Givens and Walton Goggins as Boyd Crowder. The show’s blend of modern crime drama with the essence of a Western appeals to audiences who enjoy complex storytelling with a dose of dark humor. Many admire its authentic depiction of Harlan County, Kentucky, and the nuanced exploration of morality, family ties, and justice.
—
—
What Haters Say
Critics of the show often point to its slower pacing, particularly in the early episodes, as a downside. Some viewers also feel that certain story arcs meander or fail to maintain momentum. A few detractors argue that the show leans too heavily on stylized dialogue and lacks the sustained tension found in other crime dramas.
Does the Show Fall Off in Quality at Any Point?
The consensus among critics and fans is that Justified maintains a relatively consistent level of quality throughout its six-season run. However, some note a dip in momentum during the fifth season, which introduces a new family of antagonists who are less compelling than earlier foes. Despite this, the show’s final season is widely regarded as a strong return to form, delivering a satisfying conclusion to its central character arcs.
Aggregated Critic Commentary
| Season | Rotten Tomatoes Approval | Rotten Tomatoes Average Score | IMDb Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Season 1 (2010) | 93% | 8.3/10 | 8.6/10 |
| Season 2 (2011) | 100% | 8.8/10 | 8.6/10 |
| Season 3 (2012) | 96% | 9.6/10 | 8.6/10 |
| Season 4 (2013) | 100% | 9.5/10 | 8.6/10 |
| Season 5 (2014) | 96% | 8/10 | 8.6/10 |
| Season 6 (2015) | 100% | 9/10 | 8.6/10 |
| Justified: City Primeval (2023) | 92% | 7.8/10 | 7.9/10 |
Justified received widespread critical acclaim, especially for its writing and acting. Critics often highlight the series’ ability to blend pulpy, violent storytelling with philosophical undertones and sharp wit. The show earned multiple Emmy nominations, with standout recognition for guest performances and its writing. Its ability to weave a serialized story while delivering compelling, episodic narratives is frequently commended.
Overview of the Show
Based on Elmore Leonard’s novella Fire in the Hole, Justified follows the exploits of Raylan Givens, a U.S. Marshal with a 19th-century gunslinger’s approach to modern law enforcement. After a controversial shooting in Miami, Raylan is reassigned to his hometown of Harlan County, Kentucky—a region rife with crime, corruption, and family feuds.
Raylan’s return puts him in conflict with Boyd Crowder, a charismatic criminal and former coal miner with whom he shares a complex history. Their cat-and-mouse dynamic, fueled by mutual respect and personal animosities, forms the heart of the series. The show delves into themes of justice, retribution, and the cyclical nature of violence, all while exploring the socio-economic struggles of Appalachia.
Throughout its run, Justified deftly balances episodic storytelling with larger narrative arcs, introducing a colorful cast of characters ranging from quirky criminals to ruthless kingpins. Its sharp, Leonard-inspired dialogue, along with its fusion of Western tropes and crime drama sensibilities, sets it apart from other procedurals.
Season Highlights
Season 1
The first season establishes Raylan Givens’ reluctant return to Kentucky and his tense reunion with Boyd Crowder, who survives a near-fatal shooting by Raylan in the pilot episode. The season balances standalone cases with a developing story about Boyd’s religious conversion and criminal ambitions. Notable moments include Raylan’s confrontation with his estranged father, Arlo, and the introduction of Ava Crowder, Boyd’s sister-in-law and Raylan’s initial love interest.
Season 2
Widely regarded as the show’s finest season, the second season introduces the Bennett family, led by the chilling matriarch Mags Bennett (Margo Martindale). The story focuses on land disputes, criminal enterprises, and Mags’s deadly blend of charm and ruthlessness. The season’s emotional core lies in the tragic arc of Loretta McCready, a teenage girl caught between the Bennetts and Raylan’s efforts to protect her. The finale delivers a tense and unforgettable showdown.
Season 3
This season brings the arrival of new antagonists, including Detroit mob enforcer Robert Quarles (Neal McDonough) and cunning Dixie Mafia member Limehouse (Mykelti Williamson). The power struggles and alliances within Harlan reach new levels of complexity. Raylan’s personal life becomes increasingly strained as his ex-wife Winona becomes pregnant, adding further stakes to his dangerous profession.
Season 4
A mystery from Harlan’s past drives the fourth season’s plot, centered around the hunt for a fugitive known as “Drew Thompson.” The storyline intertwines with Raylan’s personal quest to uncover family secrets. The season’s structure, focusing on a single mystery, offers a refreshing change of pace while maintaining the series’ signature tension and sharp dialogue.
Season 5
Season five introduces the Crowe family, led by the unpredictable Daryl Crowe Jr. (Michael Rapaport). While this season features memorable moments and strong performances, the Crowes are often cited as less compelling antagonists compared to previous villains. The season’s narrative complexity occasionally falters, but Raylan’s ongoing struggles with fatherhood and his own moral code remain engaging.
Season 6
The final season returns to the core conflict between Raylan and Boyd, with Ava caught in the middle as a reluctant informant. Themes of loyalty, betrayal, and inevitability dominate the narrative, culminating in a tense, emotionally resonant series finale. The conclusion honors the show’s Western roots while delivering poignant character resolutions.
Similar Shows
- Deadwood – Another Western-themed drama starring Timothy Olyphant, known for its rich language and morally complex characters.
- Fargo – A crime anthology series with dark humor and quirky, dangerous characters.
- The Shield – A gritty look at law enforcement and moral ambiguity, featuring compelling performances and intense storytelling.
- Breaking Bad – Explores the transformation of a mild-mannered man into a criminal mastermind, with themes of justice and consequence.
- Bosch – A modern detective series with a focus on procedural detail and character-driven storytelling.
If You Liked These, You’ll Like This Show
- Longmire – A modern Western crime drama with a strong, brooding protagonist and themes of justice and personal demons.
- Sons of Anarchy – A violent, character-driven drama about a motorcycle club grappling with loyalty, family, and law enforcement.
- Hell on Wheels – A historical Western series centered around revenge, railroads, and frontier justice.
- Terriers – A quirky, character-rich crime series blending humor and drama, often underappreciated but beloved by its fans.