When Does Downton Abbey Get Good?
A timepiece series, fans of Downton Abbey would tell a new viewer they’ll know whether or not they’ll like the show within the first season, likely even after a couple episodes. If you’re enjoying those, feel confident that you can keep going, and if you’re not, that opinion is unlikely to change.
What Fans Say:
Fans of Downton Abbey praise the series for its intricate storytelling, rich character development, and attention to historical detail. The interplay between the upstairs aristocrats and the downstairs servants is a standout, providing a nuanced depiction of early 20th-century British society. Viewers often highlight the lavish costumes, breathtaking settings, and compelling drama that seamlessly blends historical events with personal stories. Characters such as Violet Crawley, the Dowager Countess, are beloved for their sharp wit, while relationships like that of Anna and Mr. Bates are hailed as heartwarming and poignant.
—
—
What Haters Say:
Critics of the show argue that it leans too heavily on melodrama, particularly in later seasons. Some viewers feel the narrative occasionally sacrifices realism for the sake of sensational twists, such as sudden deaths and improbable recoveries. Others critique the portrayal of class dynamics as overly romanticized, glossing over the harsher realities of servitude and aristocratic privilege. Additionally, detractors mention that some storylines feel repetitive or contrived, particularly as the series progresses.
Does the Show Fall Off in Quality at Any Point?
The consensus is that Downton Abbey maintains a high standard of quality throughout its run, though some fans note a slight decline in later seasons. The initial seasons are praised for their tightly woven narratives and historical relevance, while later seasons occasionally rely on more soapy plotlines. The departure of key characters, such as Matthew Crawley and Sybil Branson, marked turning points that some fans found difficult to recover from. However, the series’ commitment to character arcs and thematic resolution kept it engaging until the end.
Aggregated Critic Commentary:
| Season | Rotten Tomatoes Rating | IMDb Rating |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 86% | 8.6 |
| 2 | 90% | 8.7 |
| 3 | 86% | 8.6 |
| 4 | 73% | 8.4 |
| 5 | 83% | 8.5 |
| 6 | 90% | 8.7 |
Critics widely laud Downton Abbey for its ability to blend opulent drama with historical depth. The series is often described as a cultural phenomenon that captures the zeitgeist of its era. The writing, acting, and production design receive near-universal acclaim, with many reviews highlighting the show’s ability to explore complex social changes. While some critics echo concerns about melodrama, most agree that the show’s charm and emotional resonance outweigh these flaws. Julian Fellowes, the creator, is commended for crafting a narrative that balances personal and historical narratives effectively.
Overview of the Show:
Downton Abbey, created by Julian Fellowes, is a British period drama that aired from 2010 to 2015. Set in the fictional Yorkshire country estate of Downton Abbey, the series begins in 1912 with the sinking of the Titanic and spans over a decade, covering major historical events like World War I, the Spanish flu pandemic, and the rise of the working class. At its core, the show examines the lives of the Crawley family, headed by Robert and Cora, and their servants, as they navigate personal and societal changes.
The series is renowned for its rich characters, from the acerbic Dowager Countess to the ambitious butler Thomas Barrow. It weaves together themes of love, loyalty, ambition, and societal duty. Through its six seasons, Downton Abbey explores the impact of modernization on the British aristocracy, offering a poignant look at a world on the brink of transformation. Its stunning visuals, memorable performances, and heartfelt storytelling have cemented it as a landmark in television history.
Season Highlights:
Season 1:
The series opens with the Crawley family grappling with the Titanic tragedy, which claims the lives of Robert’s heirs. This sets up a succession crisis, introducing Matthew Crawley, a distant cousin and the new heir. Key events include the blossoming romance between Matthew and Lady Mary, the scheming of footman Thomas Barrow, and the development of Anna and Bates’ relationship. The season also introduces themes of class division and the looming societal changes of the 20th century.
Season 2:
Set during World War I, this season delves into the impact of the war on Downton and its inhabitants. Matthew goes to war, and his engagement to Lavinia Swire complicates his relationship with Mary. Sybil’s romance with chauffeur Tom Branson sparks controversy. The servants’ lives are equally tumultuous, with Thomas’ wartime experiences and Bates’ legal troubles taking center stage. The season’s emotional depth and historical context make it a fan favorite.
Season 3:
This season focuses on recovery and adaptation post-war. Mary and Matthew marry, but tragedy strikes with Matthew’s untimely death in the finale. The Crawleys face financial difficulties, leading to a pivotal storyline about saving the estate. Edith’s foray into journalism and her budding romance add complexity to her character. Below stairs, the relationships and rivalries among the servants continue to evolve.
Season 4:
The aftermath of Matthew’s death dominates the narrative, as Mary struggles to move forward. The introduction of new love interests for Mary, including Lord Gillingham and Charles Blake, sparks intrigue. Edith faces heartbreak and scandal with her pregnancy out of wedlock. Meanwhile, the servants navigate their own dramas, including Anna’s traumatic assault and Bates’ quest for justice. This season’s darker tone adds a layer of emotional complexity.
Season 5:
As societal changes accelerate, the Crawleys adapt to new realities. Mary’s romantic pursuits continue, while Edith secretly raises her illegitimate daughter. Robert’s resistance to modernization contrasts with Tom’s progressive views. Below stairs, Thomas’ struggles with his identity and Mrs. Hughes and Carson’s blossoming romance provide poignant moments. The season reflects the tension between tradition and progress.
Season 6:
The final season ties up loose ends, offering satisfying resolutions for many characters. Mary finds happiness with Henry Talbot, while Edith finally achieves her fairy-tale ending with Bertie Pelham. The servants also see significant changes, with Thomas finding acceptance and Carson retiring. The series ends on a hopeful note, emphasizing the enduring spirit of Downton Abbey and its inhabitants.
Similar Shows:
- The Crown – A historical drama focusing on the British monarchy, with lavish production and intricate storytelling.
- Upstairs, Downstairs – A classic series that explores the lives of aristocrats and servants in early 20th-century London.
- Call the Midwife – A period drama centered on midwives in post-war East London, blending historical themes with heartfelt narratives.
- Victoria – A series chronicling the early reign of Queen Victoria, rich in historical detail and personal drama.
- Poldark – A romantic period drama set in 18th-century Cornwall, exploring themes of love, class, and resilience.
If You Liked These, You’ll Like This Show:
- Mad Men – Though set in a different era, it offers a similar exploration of societal change and personal ambition.
- Bridgerton – A Regency-era drama with a focus on romance, societal expectations, and family dynamics.
- The Gilded Age – From Julian Fellowes, this series explores the opulence and intrigue of 19th-century New York.
- Anne with an E – A reimagining of Anne of Green Gables that blends period aesthetics with modern emotional depth.