When Does Gilmore Girls Get Good?
Fans of Gilmore Girls absolutely adore almost every episode and season of this show. With that in mind, if you’re not finding yourself enjoying the series after the first couple of episodes that likely won’t change. That being said, for those that think they’re interested after a few episodes, the rest of the series will likely provide a rewarding and feel-good television series that fans say they rewatch often.
What Fans Say
Fans of Gilmore Girls adore its witty, fast-paced dialogue, relatable mother-daughter dynamics, and the idyllic small-town charm of Stars Hollow. The bond between Lorelai and Rory Gilmore resonates deeply, offering a heartfelt depiction of family, friendship, and personal growth. Viewers also praise the ensemble cast, quirky supporting characters, and the show’s balance of humor and emotional depth. Themes like ambition, love, and identity are explored in ways that feel authentic and inspiring to many.
—
—
What Haters Say
Critics of Gilmore Girls often take issue with its overly polished portrayal of relationships and its sometimes idealized view of small-town life. Some viewers find Lorelai and Rory’s rapid-fire dialogue unrealistic or pretentious. Others argue that certain characters or plotlines—such as Rory’s romantic entanglements or Lorelai’s stubbornness—become repetitive or frustrating over time. Additionally, the show’s tone and pacing don’t appeal to everyone, with some labeling it as overly sentimental.
Does the Show Fall Off in Quality?
Many fans agree that the show begins to decline in quality during its sixth season, when the focus shifts to more melodramatic storylines. The seventh season, created without series creator Amy Sherman-Palladino, is seen by some as lacking the original spark and consistency. Despite this, the series finale provides a bittersweet conclusion, and the Netflix revival Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life offers a mix of nostalgia and divisive new directions for the characters.
Aggregated Critic Commentary
| Season | IMDb Rating | Rotten Tomatoes Audience Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Season 1 | 8.4/10 | ~88% |
| Season 2 | 8.5/10 | ~90% |
| Season 3 | 8.5/10 | ~89% |
| Season 4 | 8.3/10 | ~85% |
| Season 5 | 8.2/10 | ~88% |
| Season 6 | 8.0/10 | ~78% |
| Season 7 | 7.7/10 | ~75% |
Critics have generally lauded Gilmore Girls for its sharp writing, compelling characters, and unique tone. The series is celebrated for its ability to blend humor with heartfelt moments, showcasing a rare and dynamic female relationship at its core. However, reviews also highlight uneven seasons, with some criticizing the later episodes for veering too far into soap-opera territory. Overall, the show’s charm and emotional resonance ensure its lasting impact as a classic of early 2000s television.
Overview of the Show
Gilmore Girls is a dramedy centered on Lorelai Gilmore (Lauren Graham) and her teenage daughter Rory (Alexis Bledel). Set in the picturesque New England town of Stars Hollow, the series follows their lives as they navigate relationships, career aspirations, and the complexities of family dynamics.
Lorelai, a fiercely independent single mother, strives to provide Rory with opportunities she didn’t have, while dealing with her own fraught relationship with her wealthy parents, Emily and Richard. Rory, an ambitious and intelligent young woman, dreams of attending Harvard and navigating the challenges of adolescence.
The show is known for its whip-smart dialogue, pop-culture references, and rich cast of supporting characters, including Lorelai’s best friend Sookie (Melissa McCarthy), local diner owner Luke (Scott Patterson), and Rory’s high school sweetheart Dean (Jared Padalecki). Over seven seasons, Gilmore Girls weaves an intricate tapestry of humor, heart, and life’s everyday challenges.
Season Highlights
Season 1 (2000-2001):
Introduces Stars Hollow and the central characters. Highlights include Lorelai rekindling a relationship with her parents to fund Rory’s education at the prestigious Chilton prep school, and Rory’s budding romance with Dean. The tone is light yet poignant, setting the stage for the series.
Season 2 (2001-2002):
Focuses on Rory’s deepening relationships and Lorelai’s romantic entanglements, including her engagement to Max. Memorable moments include the town’s quirky festivals and the introduction of Jess, a brooding love interest for Rory.
Season 3 (2002-2003):
Sees Rory preparing for college and exploring her feelings for Jess, while Lorelai works on opening her inn. The season finale, with Rory graduating and Lorelai bidding farewell to a chapter in their lives, is particularly touching.
Season 4 (2003-2004):
Explores Rory’s transition to college life at Yale and Lorelai’s progress with the Dragonfly Inn. Rory’s burgeoning relationship with Logan adds intrigue, and Lorelai’s chemistry with Luke begins to take center stage.
Season 5 (2004-2005):
Centers on Lorelai and Luke’s romantic relationship and Rory’s entanglements with Logan. The season ends with significant emotional upheavals, including Rory taking a break from Yale and Lorelai proposing to Luke.
Season 6 (2005-2006):
Marks a more dramatic shift as Rory rebels against Lorelai’s expectations, moving in with her grandparents and taking a hiatus from school. Lorelai and Luke face challenges, particularly surrounding Luke’s discovery of a long-lost daughter.
Season 7 (2006-2007):
Without Amy Sherman-Palladino at the helm, this season struggles with pacing and character consistency. However, it concludes with Rory embarking on a journalism career and Lorelai reconciling with Luke, providing a satisfying emotional sendoff.
Similar Shows
- Parenthood – Shares themes of family dynamics and emotional storytelling, with Lauren Graham in a starring role.
- Dawson’s Creek – Offers a mix of coming-of-age drama and romance in a small-town setting.
- Everwood – Balances heartfelt family relationships with a small-town atmosphere.
- Jane the Virgin – Combines humor and drama with strong female-led storytelling.
- Hart of Dixie – Centers on a young professional in a charming small town, featuring a mix of humor and romance.
If You Liked These, You’ll Like Gilmore Girls
- This Is Us – Delivers emotional family drama with sharp character writing.
- Felicity – Focuses on a young woman navigating life, love, and ambition.
- One Tree Hill – Features complex relationships and small-town dynamics.
- The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel – Another Amy Sherman-Palladino creation, offering sharp dialogue and a strong female lead.