When Does Mad Men Get Good?
Mad Men will grab a potential new fan’s attention immediately with the slick characters, time-honoring setting, and fascinating dramatic plot. Most fans would tell a new viewer if they’re not wow-ed immediately, this is unlikely to change, but for those on the fence, giving the show the first two seasons to turn you into a total fan can be well worth it as the series remains high quality throughout its entire run.
What Fans Say
Mad Men is often celebrated as a masterpiece of modern television, praised for its intricate storytelling, stunning period-accurate aesthetics, and deep character development. Fans love the show’s ability to immerse them in the advertising world of the 1960s, exploring themes like identity, ambition, and societal change. Don Draper’s enigmatic persona is a constant point of intrigue, as is the nuanced portrayal of complex characters like Peggy Olson and Joan Holloway. The show’s subtle and reflective narrative style, combined with its sharp critique of gender roles and corporate culture, keeps fans hooked.
—
—
What Haters Say
Critics of Mad Men often find its slow pacing to be off-putting, particularly for viewers accustomed to more action-driven dramas. Some feel the series focuses too much on style over substance, with long stretches of dialogue that don’t seem to advance the plot. A few detractors argue that Don Draper’s character, while compelling, becomes repetitive in his flaws and self-destructive tendencies. The show’s refusal to offer clear resolutions for many subplots also leaves some viewers frustrated.
Does the Show Fall Off in Quality at Any Point?
The consensus is that Mad Men remains consistent in quality throughout its seven-season run. However, some fans feel that the middle seasons, especially Season 5, stray slightly into repetitive territory with Don’s personal struggles. Others argue that the final season’s split into two halves diluted its emotional impact. Still, the majority believe the series delivers a strong and satisfying conclusion.
Aggregated Critic Commentary
| Season | Rotten Tomatoes Rating | IMDb Rating (Average) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 97% | 8.7 |
| 2 | 96% | 8.8 |
| 3 | 96% | 8.9 |
| 4 | 97% | 9.0 |
| 5 | 98% | 9.1 |
| 6 | 98% | 8.9 |
| 7 | 92% | 9.0 |
Critics universally praise Mad Men as a landmark series that helped cement television as a serious storytelling medium. It has been lauded for its rich character studies, historical accuracy, and its exploration of themes like consumerism and identity. The writing, performances—particularly by Jon Hamm, Elisabeth Moss, and Christina Hendricks—and period-accurate production design have received widespread acclaim. The show has won multiple Emmys, Golden Globes, and critical accolades for its cultural and artistic significance.
Overview of Mad Men
Mad Men, created by Matthew Weiner, is a groundbreaking period drama that aired from 2007 to 2015. Set primarily in 1960s New York, the series centers on Don Draper, a mysterious and brilliant ad executive at the fictional Sterling Cooper Advertising Agency. The show delves into the lives of its characters as they navigate the complexities of their personal and professional worlds during a time of profound social change.
Through its seven seasons, Mad Men explores the shifting cultural landscape of America—from the rise of counterculture movements to evolving gender dynamics and workplace politics. With impeccable attention to detail, the series authentically captures the era’s fashion, music, and cultural attitudes, offering viewers a window into the Golden Age of advertising.
At its core, Mad Men is about identity: how we create, sell, and struggle with it. Don Draper’s journey, marked by secrets, reinventions, and personal failures, serves as the emotional anchor of the series. Meanwhile, characters like Peggy Olson and Joan Holloway break barriers in a male-dominated industry, offering narratives of empowerment and resilience.
Whether you’re drawn to its incisive social commentary, its complex characters, or its gorgeous production design, Mad Men is a show that invites and rewards deep engagement.
Season Highlights
Season 1 (2007)
The series opens with Don Draper, the enigmatic creative director at Sterling Cooper, crafting ad campaigns while hiding a mysterious past. The first season introduces key characters like Peggy Olson, a secretary who begins her journey in advertising, and Betty Draper, Don’s wife, whose seemingly idyllic suburban life masks deep dissatisfaction. Themes of sexism, infidelity, and ambition are established, with a standout episode exploring Don’s wartime backstory.
Season 2 (2008)
As Sterling Cooper navigates changes in the advertising world, personal lives become even more entangled. Peggy’s professional growth contrasts with Don’s unraveling marriage to Betty. The Cuban Missile Crisis looms large, symbolizing the era’s anxieties. The season also delves into Don’s existential crises, solidifying the show’s introspective tone.
Season 3 (2009)
The third season marks significant changes at Sterling Cooper, culminating in a thrilling agency shakeup. Betty discovers Don’s secrets, leading to their separation. The season’s finale is a fan favorite, as the core team takes bold steps to reclaim control of their professional lives.
Season 4 (2010)
Now at the newly formed Sterling Cooper Draper Pryce, Don struggles with single fatherhood and his drinking. Peggy continues to rise as a creative force, and Joan’s complicated personal life takes center stage. The season balances moments of triumph with the heavy toll of ambition, with the standout episode “The Suitcase” being a critical darling.
Season 5 (2012)
This season introduces Megan Draper as Don’s new wife, with her vibrant energy contrasting his brooding nature. Themes of disillusionment and loss dominate, with Lane Pryce’s tragic arc standing out. Critics noted this season for its emotional weight and powerful performances.
Season 6 (2013)
Don’s downward spiral accelerates, jeopardizing his career and relationships. Meanwhile, the agency expands its reach, mirroring the cultural upheavals of the late ’60s. Sally Draper, Don’s daughter, emerges as a compelling character, reflecting the generational divide.
Season 7 (2014–2015)
Split into two parts, the final season explores themes of legacy, change, and redemption. Don’s journey concludes with one of television’s most debated and iconic endings. Peggy and Joan’s arcs highlight the evolving roles of women in the workplace, while the show’s commitment to nuanced storytelling ensures a memorable finale.
Similar Shows
- The Sopranos
A similarly character-driven drama, this series explores the duality of personal and professional lives, with themes of identity and moral ambiguity. - The Wire
Known for its complex characters and social commentary, this show, like Mad Men, challenges viewers to engage deeply with its narrative. - Breaking Bad
This gripping series shares Mad Men‘s focus on transformation and flawed characters, making it a favorite among fans of intense dramas. - Six Feet Under
A thoughtful exploration of family and personal struggles, this show offers the emotional depth and introspection that fans of Mad Men will appreciate. - Boardwalk Empire
Set in a different era, this series combines historical authenticity with a focus on power dynamics and complex characters.
If You Liked These, You’ll Like This Show
- Succession
With its sharp writing and focus on dysfunctional power struggles, Succession captures a similar blend of intrigue and character drama. - Halt and Catch Fire
This series about the tech industry in the 1980s offers compelling characters and a richly detailed period setting. - The Americans
A Cold War-era drama that combines suspense with deep character exploration, this show resonates with fans of Mad Men‘s layered storytelling. - The Crown
For viewers who enjoy historical settings and character-driven narratives, The Crown delivers both with lavish production and emotional depth.