When Does The West Wing Get Good?
Most fans of The West Wing will argue in favor of a show that had a good run throughout the entire series, but there is a noticeable shift from Aaron Sorkin’s style through the first four seasons and the remainder of the show. You’ll know within the first few episodes if this is a show for you, and while some might argue the show falls off in quality a bit in later seasons, they’ll most likely still tell you the show remains enjoyable for the full run.
What Fans Say
Fans of The West Wing adore its intelligent and optimistic portrayal of government. The series offers an aspirational view of politics, showing a team of dedicated professionals striving to make ethical choices under pressure. Key aspects fans appreciate include:
- Dialogue and Writing: Aaron Sorkin’s scripts are packed with witty exchanges and passionate monologues.
- Cast Chemistry: The camaraderie among the ensemble cast, particularly Bartlet’s senior staff, is a core strength.
- Relatability Amid Complexity: Fans praise the balance of accessible storytelling with complex political issues.
- Emotional Impact: From moments of triumph to heartbreak, the show often leaves viewers deeply moved.
—
—
What Haters Say
Criticism of The West Wing often comes from viewers who find its idealism unrealistic or its tone overly preachy. Common critiques include:
- Simplified Politics: Detractors argue the show occasionally reduces complex political issues into feel-good resolutions.
- Character Arcs: Some characters, such as Sam Seaborn or Mandy Hampton, exit abruptly, frustrating viewers.
- Later Seasons: Critics of Seasons 5–7 cite a drop in quality after Sorkin’s departure, with inconsistent writing and pacing.
- Pacing Issues: While the “walk-and-talk” style is iconic, some felt it could become repetitive.
Does the Show Fall Off in Quality?
The general consensus is that The West Wing experiences a noticeable shift in tone and quality after Season 4. Aaron Sorkin, the show’s visionary creator, left after the fourth season due to creative differences and personal challenges. While Seasons 5 and 6 have moments of brilliance, they lack the tight focus and ideological consistency of earlier seasons. Season 7, however, earned praise for its gripping portrayal of a presidential campaign, offering a strong conclusion to the series.
Overview of The West Wing
The West Wing, created by Aaron Sorkin, debuted in 1999 and quickly became one of television’s most celebrated dramas. The show provides a fictional glimpse into the workings of the White House under the administration of President Josiah “Jed” Bartlet (played by Martin Sheen). With a sharp focus on political strategy, moral dilemmas, and interpersonal relationships, The West Wing blends idealism with realism, portraying a world where intelligence, wit, and principles shape governance.
Praised for its snappy dialogue and innovative “walk-and-talk” scenes, the series delves into policy debates, media relations, and the human toll of political life. Beyond politics, it’s a character-driven show that explores themes of loyalty, integrity, and the balance of power. The show’s ensemble cast—including Allison Janney, Bradley Whitford, Richard Schiff, Rob Lowe, and John Spencer—delivers standout performances, bringing authenticity and emotion to the fast-paced West Wing setting.
Over seven seasons, The West Wing faced shifts in tone, especially after Sorkin’s departure following Season 4. While some fans felt later seasons lacked the sharpness of earlier episodes, others appreciated the broader focus on new characters and campaign storylines.
Aggregated Critic Commentary
| Season | Rotten Tomatoes (%) | IMDb Rating (Avg) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 96% | 8.8 |
| 2 | 97% | 9.1 |
| 3 | 90% | 8.7 |
| 4 | 93% | 8.6 |
| 5 | 76% | 8.1 |
| 6 | 80% | 8.2 |
| 7 | 90% | 8.6 |
Critics lauded The West Wing during its initial run, frequently praising its sophisticated storytelling, sharp dialogue, and exceptional performances. It became a cultural touchstone, earning numerous Emmy Awards, including four consecutive wins for Outstanding Drama Series.
Critics often highlight:
- Cultural Impact: The West Wing influenced public perceptions of politics, inspiring discussions about leadership and integrity.
- Character Depth: Even minor characters are well-rounded, with personal struggles and growth arcs.
- Ethical Complexity: The show delves into dilemmas without easy answers, offering a nuanced view of decision-making.
However, post-Sorkin seasons received mixed reviews, with some critics appreciating the new direction and others lamenting the loss of the creator’s signature style.
Season Highlights (100-200 Words Per Season)
Season 1
The inaugural season introduces the Bartlet administration, showcasing the dynamics of senior staffers like Leo McGarry, C.J. Cregg, and Josh Lyman. Highlights include Bartlet standing up to religious extremists and the tragic story of Josh’s sister.
Season 2
A standout season that balances emotional depth and political drama, including the aftermath of an assassination attempt. The two-part “In the Shadow of Two Gunmen” reveals backstories for key characters.
Season 3
Focuses on Bartlet’s battle with public and personal fallout after revealing his MS diagnosis. Storylines about terrorism and international diplomacy add urgency, while personal arcs grow deeper.
Season 4
Features Bartlet’s re-election campaign and increasingly high-stakes decisions. The season ends with a dramatic cliffhanger: the kidnapping of Zoey Bartlet.
Season 5
The post-Sorkin era begins with uneven pacing but retains moments of brilliance. The focus shifts to global issues, including Middle Eastern peace efforts.
Season 6
Centered around the search for Bartlet’s successor, the season introduces compelling new candidates, including Matt Santos. The campaign energizes the narrative.
Season 7
A politically charged season that chronicles the Santos-Vinick campaign. Its finale, “Tomorrow,” offers a heartfelt farewell to the Bartlet era, leaving fans with closure.
Similar Shows To The West Wing
- House of Cards (Netflix): A darker, more cynical take on politics.
- Madam Secretary (CBS): Balances political drama with personal storytelling.
- Veep (HBO): A satirical and humorous look at modern governance.
- Designated Survivor (ABC): Political leadership in the face of crisis.
- The Newsroom (HBO): Another Aaron Sorkin masterpiece, exploring journalism.
If You Liked These, You’ll Like The West Wing
- The Crown (Netflix): A character-driven study of leadership.
- Friday Night Lights (NBC): Emotional storytelling with a strong ensemble cast.
- Parenthood (NBC): Relatable drama and heartfelt moments, similar to Bartlet’s family dynamics.
- Scandal (ABC): High-stakes drama and moral ambiguity in Washington, D.C.