When Does Schitt’s Creek Get Good?
Fans of Schitt’s Creek argue that it’ll take a new viewer about half of the first season to get to know the characters of this hit comedy series, but after that, if they’re still wanting more, they’re in for a great ride the remainder of the series. The show hits its stride in the second season and remains strong throughout.
The show is praised as being easy-viewing comedy, where the more a viewer gets to know the characters, the funnier the scenarios they are in each episode and season get funnier. Definitely a show that’s easy to fall in love with quick, and it’ll be obvious after the first few episodes if it’s worth it for you to keep going or not.
What Fans Say
Fans of Schitt’s Creek praise the show for its heartwarming and hopeful approach to humor. The Rose family’s journey from entitled and out-of-touch to sincere and self-aware resonates with viewers, particularly through character development that balances humor with depth. David Rose’s journey, in particular, stands out as he finds both personal fulfillment and love in the form of his relationship with Patrick. The show’s portrayal of LGBTQ+ relationships without the presence of stereotypical storylines or major obstacles is widely celebrated, as it offers an unproblematic, feel-good romance that is rare in television.
The comedy itself also garners high praise, as fans love the witty banter and one-liners from characters like Moira, whose eccentric fashion and vocabulary add a unique flair. Fans find joy in watching the Roses’ transformation, but they also value the close-knit, supportive town of Schitt’s Creek, where the characters’ quirks are embraced rather than criticized. Many see Schitt’s Creek as a comfort show, particularly enjoying the warmth and light-heartedness it brings, even amid moments of tension.
—
—
What Haters Say
While Schitt’s Creek enjoys widespread acclaim, some detractors find its pacing and humor style to be acquired tastes. The first season, in particular, has been noted as slow-moving by some, with viewers either adjusting to or feeling alienated by the exaggerated behavior and self-centeredness of the main characters. Additionally, the show’s dialogue-centric and character-driven humor does not appeal to everyone, as some prefer more action-driven comedy.
Critics who dislike the show occasionally argue that the Roses’ privilege and eccentricities aren’t entirely relatable, especially in the early episodes when they are more detached and materialistic. Others feel the show’s episodic structure can make it repetitive, with the Roses continually finding themselves in familiar scenarios without substantial movement in the plot until later seasons. However, most agree that the show’s charm grows over time, and it becomes rewarding as the characters evolve.
Does the Show Fall Off in Quality at Any Point?
Many fans and critics believe Schitt’s Creek maintained a steady upward trajectory in quality. While the first season received mixed reviews, the characters and humor began to resonate more in subsequent seasons as the Roses integrated more into the town. By season three, the show’s reputation had grown substantially, with viewers appreciating the emotional depth alongside the comedy.
In its final season, Schitt’s Creek received record-breaking critical acclaim, notably sweeping the 2020 Emmy Awards in the comedy category. The show’s final episodes are celebrated for tying up character arcs satisfyingly, leaving fans feeling a sense of closure. Generally, audiences and critics agree that Schitt’s Creek didn’t fall in quality, instead evolving into a beloved and critically lauded series.
Aggregated Critic Commentary
| Season | IMDb Rating | Rotten Tomatoes (Tomatometer) | Rotten Tomatoes (Audience Score) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Season 1 | 7.6 | 67% | 81% |
| Season 2 | 8.0 | 100% | 87% |
| Season 3 | 8.1 | 100% | 93% |
| Season 4 | 8.3 | 100% | 91% |
| Season 5 | 8.3 | 100% | 92% |
| Season 6 | 8.5 | 100% | 96% |
Critics often highlight the show’s unique ability to blend humor with emotional depth. Schitt’s Creek is lauded for its progressive approach, particularly in its portrayal of queer relationships and its decision to focus on acceptance and inclusivity. Patrick and David’s relationship was groundbreaking for many viewers, as it avoided the “coming out” narrative and focused on a love story without tragedy or tension—a rarity on television.
The Guardian described Schitt’s Creek as a “profoundly hopeful show,” commending it for its simple yet effective way of exploring family dynamics. Critics appreciate the show’s writing, with Dan Levy’s character work receiving particular praise for making each individual arc meaningful. The humor, while quirky, is also acknowledged as refreshing, with Moira’s eccentricity and Johnny’s dry humor adding to the distinct character lineup. As the series grew, its ability to balance laughs with moments of poignancy became one of its defining strengths, making it a favorite among both casual viewers and critics.
Overview of Schitt’s Creek
Schitt’s Creek is a Canadian sitcom created by father-son duo Eugene and Dan Levy, who also star in the show. It tells the story of the wealthy Rose family—Johnny, Moira, David, and Alexis—who lose their fortune and are forced to relocate to Schitt’s Creek, a small town they once bought as a joke. Adjusting to life without wealth, they live in a rundown motel and navigate their newfound circumstances with humor, humanity, and growth. The show explores themes of family, resilience, and self-discovery, using the town and its quirky residents to push the Roses out of their comfort zones.
The initial humor of Schitt’s Creek often comes from the Roses’ struggle to adapt, with their exaggerated quirks and obliviousness to small-town life playing into comedic moments. As the series progresses, however, Schitt’s Creek shifts from being simply a comedy about rich people adjusting to the “ordinary” to a story of transformation. The family members, who begin as self-absorbed and materialistic, develop deep bonds, with the show ending in a place of genuine connection and acceptance. Schitt’s Creek became a pop culture phenomenon, winning several Emmy Awards and earning critical acclaim for its LGBTQ+ representation, warm storytelling, and endearing characters.
Season Highlights
Season 1
The first season introduces the Roses and their transition to Schitt’s Creek. Much of the humor arises from the family’s bewilderment as they adapt to their new reality. Highlights include Moira and David’s attempts at small-town life and Alexis navigating romance with Mutt, her polar opposite. Season 1 sets the foundation for each character’s growth and establishes their unique dynamics with the townspeople.
Season 2
In Season 2, the Roses begin to invest more in the town and in each other. Johnny tries to revive his career with Roland’s help, while David and Stevie’s complex friendship deepens, adding layers to David’s personality. Alexis’ relationship with Ted also adds emotional stakes. This season is where the Roses start showing hints of self-awareness, moving beyond just comedic caricatures.
Season 3
Season 3 sees the Roses becoming even more integrated into the community. David opens his boutique, Rose Apothecary, which becomes a symbol of his newfound independence and identity. Alexis returns to high school, showing significant personal growth. The season also introduces Patrick, David’s business partner and love interest, sparking one of television’s most beloved relationships.
Season 4
The relationship between David and Patrick takes center stage in Season 4, which contains some of the series’ most heartfelt moments. Moira’s career prospects shift, and Johnny continues to find purpose in managing the motel. The family’s relationships with the townspeople deepen, reflecting their personal growth.
Season 5
In Season 5, Moira lands a role in The Crows Have Eyes III, bringing her a sense of professional pride. The season also features David and Patrick’s engagement, a highly anticipated moment that fans adored. This season emphasizes family bonds, particularly in how the Roses now support each other’s dreams.
Season 6
The final season ties up each character’s arc. David and Patrick’s wedding becomes a central focus, while Johnny and Moira make big decisions about their future. The finale, celebrated by critics and fans alike, offers closure and encapsulates the show’s themes of growth, acceptance, and love.
Similar Shows
If you enjoyed Schitt’s Creek, here are some similar shows that may resonate:
- Parks and Recreation – Known for its quirky characters and small-town setting, Parks and Rec has a similar blend of humor and heart.
- The Good Place – Both shows delve into self-improvement and redemption with a humorous approach, focusing on character development in unique settings.
- Brooklyn Nine-Nine – With an ensemble cast and emphasis on character growth, Brooklyn Nine-Nine brings laughs with heartfelt moments, similar to Schitt’s Creek.
- Kim’s Convenience – Another Canadian sitcom, Kim’s Convenience explores family dynamics and cultural identity in a way that Schitt’s Creek fans may appreciate.
- Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt – Featuring a fish-out-of-water storyline, Kimmy Schmidt brings quirky humor with a focus on personal growth and resilience.
If You Like These, You’ll Like Schitt’s Creek
- Arrested Development – With a storyline about a family losing their fortune, Arrested Development has a similar comedic premise, though its humor is often darker.
- Grace and Frankie – Focusing on an unlikely friendship and reinvention, Grace and Frankie provides a humorous take on starting over.
- Superstore – A workplace comedy with quirky characters and a strong sense of community, Superstore shares Schitt’s Creek’s emphasis on relationships.
- Ted Lasso – Known for its optimistic outlook and character-driven comedy, Ted Lasso balances humor with heartwarming moments similar to Schitt’s Creek.