When does RDR2 Get good?
While it can be daunting to commit to a 60-100 hour game, RDR2 rewards users with a beautiful journey where you’ll get the most out of the game if you don’t rush through the story and instead enjoy your time role-playing as a cowboy trying to make sense of the decaying west.
RDR2 can feel slow at the start as characters are introduced, and many argue the first act is the weakest. Most fans argue players need to give the game 10-20 hours before it hits its strongest stride.
What Fans Say:
—
—
Fans of Red Dead Redemption 2 praise its deep, emotionally resonant story and complex characters, especially Arthur Morgan, whose moral journey is seen as one of the most compelling in gaming. Many players highlight the game’s attention to environmental detail, from dynamic weather and wildlife to the behavior of NPCs. The freedom to make meaningful choices, the variety of side activities, and the realistic landscapes make the world feel alive and immersive. Fans appreciate the game’s balance of storytelling with player-driven exploration, viewing it as a near-cinematic experience in the medium of gaming.
What Haters Say:
Critics of Red Dead Redemption 2 often point to its pacing, which some find slow, particularly during long horse rides or scenes with minimal action. A subset of players also feels that certain game mechanics, like gunplay and movement, can be clunky or overly realistic, detracting from the fluidity of gameplay. Additionally, the game’s emphasis on realism sometimes translates to laborious mechanics (e.g., managing Arthur’s weight, grooming his horse) that some find tedious. Despite its massive success, a few players argue that the game can feel too focused on narrative at the expense of player agency.
Aggregated Critic Commentary:
Red Dead Redemption 2 received universal acclaim from critics, earning praise for its groundbreaking graphics, intricate story, and ambitious world-building. Many critics regard it as one of the most influential open-world games of its time, comparing it to cinematic masterpieces in its storytelling depth. Arthur Morgan’s character arc, coupled with the richly crafted world, has been celebrated for pushing boundaries in emotional depth within a video game.
Critics have also lauded Rockstar’s attention to historical detail, with many aspects of the environment reflecting a realistically portrayed 1899 America. The game’s pacing and realism, while divisive among players, were appreciated by critics who valued its commitment to authenticity. Some critics, however, noted that the slower pace might not appeal to every gamer, particularly those accustomed to faster, more action-oriented titles. Still, Red Dead Redemption 2 is widely recognized as a triumph in gaming, with its successes often compared to other Rockstar titles, particularly Grand Theft Auto V.
Overview of RDR2:
Red Dead Redemption 2, developed by Rockstar Games and released in 2018, is an expansive open-world action-adventure game set in the American Wild West. This prequel to the original Red Dead Redemption (2010) follows Arthur Morgan, a member of the Van der Linde gang, as he grapples with his loyalty to the gang and his moral compass. Set in 1899, as the American frontier nears its end, the story explores themes of loyalty, betrayal, survival, and the American Dream in a rapidly modernizing world.
The game’s storyline unfolds through a variety of missions, side quests, and random encounters, allowing players to explore vast landscapes—from bustling towns to rugged mountains, swamps, and plains. Players engage in activities such as hunting, fishing, crafting, and interacting with other characters, each action shaping Arthur’s honor and impacting his interactions with others. Red Dead Redemption 2 is known for its stunningly realistic graphics, nuanced character development, and meticulous attention to detail, making the player feel truly immersed in the late 19th-century American frontier.
Red Dead Redemption 2 also offers an online mode, Red Dead Online, where players can embark on missions, form gangs, and explore a multiplayer experience within the same world. With its groundbreaking visuals, complex storytelling, and freedom of exploration, the game set new standards for open-world gaming and has garnered a loyal fanbase that appreciates its mature, immersive approach to storytelling.
Similar Games:
- The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
- Assassin’s Creed Odyssey
- Grand Theft Auto V
- Horizon Zero Dawn
- Ghost of Tsushima
If You Liked These, You’ll Like “Red Dead Redemption 2”
- The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt – Known for its immersive storytelling, expansive world, and complex protagonist, The Witcher 3 provides a similar blend of narrative and exploration.
- Assassin’s Creed Odyssey – Set in a historical world, this title allows players to navigate ancient Greece with similar open-world mechanics and freedom in story choices.
- Grand Theft Auto V – Another Rockstar title, this modern crime epic shares RDR2’s dedication to open-world storytelling and freedom of choice, albeit in a contemporary setting.
- Ghost of Tsushima – Featuring a beautifully crafted historical world set in feudal Japan, this game offers a story-driven experience with a protagonist facing moral and personal dilemmas similar to Arthur Morgan’s.